Comparing dry and wet foods


I cannot find anything that tells us how the foods have been rated and whether raw, dry and wet foods have been rated in exactly the same way. Can I, for example, take a 5 star dry food and compare it like for like with a 5 star wet food? Or would a 5 star dry food be more comparable to a 3 star wet food (again, for example).

Thank you,

Hello and welcome to the forum. I don’t know if my answer is what you are looking for but according to the How are the expert ratings calculated? on the frequently asked questions page of this website, the scoring is the same for dry as for wet and is ingredient based. David is currently working on the ratings and there may be other factors involved in the scoring but that will not be until a later date. If you want to do your own scoring, you might find the Instant Review Generator helpful.

1 Like